By an Associate.
Continuing the narrative that began here.
Chapter VII.—Washington’s strategy on Long-Island.—A sudden marriage.—Escape to New-York by raft.—Attractions of New-York.—Mr. Hamilton’s Drip-Down Economics.—Loss of New-York.—Crossing the Delaware.
By the time we had left Philadelphia, Washington was on the move. He was heading for Long-Island, with the intention of preventing Howe from capturing the city of New-York. Susanna and I determined to meet him there in the town of Brooklyn, across the river from the city; and there we found him awaiting the arrival of Howe’s force. The news of independence had, of course, reached him long before we did, and the soldiers were stirred by the idea that they were now fighting for something permanent.
“So what do you intend to do to prepare for Howe’s arrival?” I asked him.
“Nothing,” Washington responded confidently.
“Nothing?” Susanna and I both repeated at once.
“Precisely,” said Washington. “You taught me that, Phillips. It worked for Forbes at Pittsburgh; it worked for us at Boston; it will work again here. Nothing, I might go so far as to say, is the greatest contribution our present age has made to the art of military strategy. In the future, wars will be fought entirely by armies doing nothing, nothing on a titanic scale; and think what a savings in men and material we shall have when opposing armies both adopt a strategy of doing nothing whatsoever! Furthermore, as doing nothing has been demonstrated to be the strategy that procures victory, both sides in future wars will invariably be victorious. There will be none of the bitterness of defeat and concomitant desire for revenge; but all men will live in amity in a world that is constantly at war, providing pleasant employment for young men in the armies and navies, and leaving the other classes of society to enjoy all the benefits of the profoundest peace. From now on, nothing is the strategy I intend to adopt.”
Susanna was rubbing her temples as if suffering from a headache, but she apparently was resigned enough to hold her peace.
“Meanwhile,” Washington continued, “I’ve set up my headquarters in this very commodious house, although I must say the ceilings are a bit low and the bed a bit short. I’ve set aside a room for you and Phillips to share, just upstairs and to the right, across from my own chamber.”
“I’m sure I could find something in—”
“I won’t hear of it,” Washington said with finality. “After your journey you both must be in need of a good rest, and you’ll find no accommodations but soldiers’ tents elsewhere. I should like to have you with me and Parson Weems here, so please indulge me. Now, if you’ll excuse me for a time, I have to make my usual rounds.”
He left us alone in the house, and I immediately said to Susanna, “I can sleep in the parlor.”
“It seems as if every man I meet tries to take advantage of my sex and my color,” Susanna remarked. “Except for you. You have always behaved as a gentleman to me.”
“I’ve always tried to—”
“What is wrong with you?” she demanded with sudden vehemence.
“Susanna, I would never take advantage of a lady, in spite of all the pressing temptations I suffer every time you’re near me—temptations I struggle mightily to resist, because I would not insult the finest lady I have ever known.”
“And did you think you were the only one who was tempted?”
For a moment I stood mute and looked into her eyes. Then I asked carefully, “What do you mean, Susanna?”
“I mean, obviously, that I don’t want you to sleep in the parlor.”
“Then you really do feel…some attachment to me?”
“I have a weakness for perfect gentlemen.”
I was probably gaping like a fish in a boat, because she continued:
“Mr. Gist, I know where I stand. I know I can never be more than a mistress to you. But even though—”
“By God, you’re wrong!” I cried. “Susanna, I love you, and I know I can never deserve you, but if you’re fool enough to have me, will you be my wife?”
A long interval of dreadful silence followed, until at last Susanna said quietly, “You’re mad.”
“I do believe I am. Since the moment I saw you a divine madness has taken possession of my soul, a madness that—”
“Oh, shut up!” Susanna exclaimed, and she enforced her will by pressing her lips hard against mine. She held them there until I had lost all desire to express my thoughts in articulate speech.
At last she spoke again: “I will be your wife, Mr. Gist, when we can do it, but I don’t think I can wait that long.”
“There’s a clergyman in this very house,” I reminded her.
“You mean that jackass?”
“A jackass with the power to make us both what we long to be.” I took her hand and led her up the stairs, where we found Parson Weems sitting in his little room composing a tract.
“Weems,” I said breathlessly, “marry us now.”
Weems thought for a moment and then said, “Gist, may I have a brief word with you?”
“No,” I replied. “Not without Susanna, who is bone of my bone and flesh of my flesh from this day forward.”
“You do realize that I really am a clergyman, Gist, don’t you? If I do this⁠—”
“Weems, you fool! Do you think I’m plotting to seduce this lady with a sham marriage? By heaven, I should thrash you. But wedding now, and we’ll save the thrashing for later.”
“I’ll do the wedding if you’ll forgo the thrashing.”
“Done,” I said.
“Only do it quickly,” Susanna added, clinging to me.
“All right,” said Parson Weems. “Dearly beloved, et cetera, honorable estate and so on, skip to the good part. Do you, Susanna, take this man to be your lawfully wedded husband, for better for worse, for richer for poorer, whether he snores or not, till death do you part?”
“I do,” she replied.
“And do you, Christopher, take this woman to be your lawfully wedded wife, under all the usual conditions et cetera?”
“I do,” I answered eagerly.
“Then I now sentence you to be man and wife, and may God have mercy on your souls.”
“We’re done?” asked Susanna.
“For the rest of your natural lives,” Weems replied.
Susanna yanked me out the door and into our own chamber, where what an hour before had been a dreadful temptation was now, by a few words spoken in front of the parson, mystically transformed into a sacred duty.
Our joy, though complete, was, however, short; for the next day Howe’s army appeared, and it soon became evident that Washington’s plan of doing absolutely nothing was not as effective as he had hoped. Howe had hemmed us in from both sides, and it was clear that, without something near a miracle, the army was lost.
But then the miracle came, and Susanna seized it. As evening came on, a thick fog settled in, and it was impossible to see more than a few paces in any direction.
“If only we had some way to slip across the river!” said Susanna. “We could be out of harm’s way if we had boats, or even rafts.”
“There are trees everywhere,” I said.
“But it would be impossible to reduce them to logs quickly enough to do any good,” Susanna responded.
“Are any of them cherry trees?” I asked.
“Oh!” said Parson Weems. “I see what you mean! There’s a fine large stand of black cherries right by the river.”
“Get us an axe,” I told him, “and we’ll go get Washington.”
“I don’t understand,” said Susanna. “How is it easier to make logs from cherry trees?”
“You don’t know Washington as well as we do, my love,” I replied. Then I turned to find the nearest officer, who happened to be an old captain. “We need the men together and ready to build rafts. Any rope they can find, any fabric that can be twisted into ropes—have them gather as much as they can and go down to the river by the cherry grove. We’ll provide the logs.”
We found Washington eventually. It was difficult in the fog, but we kept asking soldiers until we found the place where he had fallen off his horse. We led him to the river, where the fog, by some providential dispensation, was dissipating; and when we came to the cherry trees, Washington did not need to be told what to do. The mania took hold of him before we said anything, and Susanna watched with awe as the trees were reduced to logs in a few minutes at most, with a terrifying din that must surely have been discouraging to the enemy. As soon as it was safe to approach, the soldiers began assembling the logs into rafts; and as the rafts were assembled, they set out for the lights across the river, where the fog had now entirely cleared.
By the next morning, the entire army had slipped out of Howe’s grasp, and was safely lodged in New-York, where the local militia supplemented our forces, and for the present Howe did not dare pursue us.
New-York in those days was a much smaller town than it is today; indeed, I believe there was scarcely a building over forty storeys in the whole island. But even in those days it was a town that loved a spectacle, and the movements of troops across the river, and the prospect of imminent invasion by Howe’s army, did not prevent New-Yorkers from enjoying themselves.
Having disposed his troops as well as he could, Washington gave them a day’s leave, and he himself spent the evening with Weems, Susanna, and me indulging in his favorite entertainment. He had learned that there was a popular puppet-show all the way uptown on Fourth-street; and, asking directions, was told to walk down the stairs at the next corner. These proved to lead down to an underground chamber hollowed out of a tunnel, where two dozen or so people were standing, apparently waiting for something. In a few minutes we heard the clopping of horses’ hooves echoing in the tunnel, and a light was visible coming into the chamber. A team of eight horses entered, followed by a very long carriage; imitating the rest of the crowd, we entered the carriage, which was already stuffed with riders, so that we were forced to stand and cling to leathern straps hung from the ceiling, apparently for that purpose, as the carriage began to move and entered the dark tunnel once more.
Uncomfortable though the arrangements were, the carriage did convey us to Fourth-street, which, when we emerged from the subterranean conveyance, proved to be lined with theaters and expositions of every sort. We found the puppet-show, where we enjoyed the amusing adventures of a cast of oddly shaped befurred puppets with bulging white eyes—most of the audience laughing in delight, but Washington watching with his usual stony dignity and expressionless silence.
After the show, Parson Weems, Susanna, and I retreated to a popular tavern across the street for a bit of Madeira; but Washington’s eye was attracted by a poster advertising an exhibition in the rooms next to the tavern:
the incomparable derwin
and
the incomparable sherwin
twin brothers who are
incomparably different,
one from another
He told us he would meet us in the tavern, and went in to enjoy the exhibition. Some time later he joined us, and declared himself well pleased with what he had seen. “It really is remarkably interesting,” he said. “The men are twins, and yet you cannot imagine two men more different in every respect.”
“How did you know they were twins?” asked Parson Weems.
Washington looked surprised and shocked. “I took it upon their word as gentlemen.”
The rest of us decided not to pursue that line of inquiry. Instead, I turned the conversation to the question of what was to be done now that Howe occupied Long island and was doubtless plotting to move on New-York itself.
“Nothing,” Washington replied with confidence.
“Nothing?” Susanna repeated incredulously. “But surely what happened across the river must have persuaded you that it is necessary to do something!”
“What happened there, I am quite convinced, was entirely owing to the malevolent influence of Irving. It was not the strategy that was at fault, but merely the events.”
“But—” Susanna began, and then stopped and took a very big gulp of her Madeira.
“To my mind,” said Parson Weems, “our most pressing problem is one of money. The soldiers have not been paid for some time. If they are not paid soon, they will begin to desert.”
“They had better not,” Washington replied with some warmth. “I am not a cruel man, but I do believe in strong discipline, and if I have to send men to bed without supper, I will do it.”
“I must agree with the Parson,” I said. “Even the sternest discipline will not keep the men long if we cannot pay them what they are legitimately owed. We must find a way to persuade the Congress to deal with the question of paying the army.”
“And I’m sure the Congress will respond with alacrity once we have made our case,” said Washington. “Meanwhile, I have been thinking of erecting a fort at the northern end of the island.”
“A very good idea, General,” said Susanna, obviously pleased. “If we control the navigation up the Hudson, we deprive the enemy of the opportunity to drive a wedge between the East and the Middle.”
“True,” said Washington. “I had not thought of that. I was more interested in establishing the site of a new city on Manhattan Island—a city that, as it grows, will doubtless eclipse New-York to the south, and perhaps even absorb it; a city that will soon rival even Philadelphia as a center of our new American civilization; a city called Washington. A fort, of course, will be the seed from which such a city sprouts. And there is one more thing I’ve been thinking of, Phillips.”
“What is that, General?”
“You’re a lieutenant, aren’t you?”
“Yes, sir.”
“Would you mind terribly being a captain?”
She glanced at me, and then answered, “No, sir.”
“Good. Captain Phillips it is, then.”
Susanna smiled broadly. “Thank you, sir.”
“You are, after all, the architect of the nothing strategy, and you deserve recognition. Perhaps in the future nothing will be named for you.”
Susanna’s smile froze on her face as she repeated, “Thank you, sir.”
Washington found us lodgings in a rather large inn. Susanna and I had a room on the twenty-seventh floor, which required a bit of labor in climbing the stairs, but rewarded us with a fine view of the city. I told Susanna I was very proud to be married to the most beautiful captain in the continental army, and we spent a very pleasant night together. It would be the last pleasant night for some time.
In the morning, when we found Washington (rather late, since Susanna and I had slept but little), he was in earnest discussion with a small, energetic man who seemed to be explaining something to him, while writing or drawing something on a paper in front of him.
“Ah! Gist—Phillips—just the men I wanted to see,” Washington said when he saw us. “This is Mr. Alexander Hamilton, a young fellow who has the most amazing ideas about money. Mr. Hamilton, this is Mr. Gist, my trusted advisor; and the other young man is Captain Phillips, one of my most valuable officers.”
The small man named Hamilton looked perplexed. “Other young man?” he repeated.
“The one in the uniform, of course.”
Hamilton continued to look perplexed for a moment, and then appeared to decide that perplexity was not worth the effort. “Very pleased to meet you both, uh, gentlemen.”
“Mr. Hamilton was just explaining to me how to get all the money we need for the army,” Washington continued. “It turns out that the Congress can have all the money it wants by simply increasing military spending and lowering taxes.”
“Don’t you mean raising taxes?” Susanna asked.
“Ah! That’s the clever part,” Washington replied. “Explain it to them, Hamilton.”
Mr. Hamilton turned his paper over to its blank side and started drawing something while he spoke. “You see, military spending stimulates economic activity by creating demand for manufactured products. But higher taxes have the opposite effect by reducing the incentive to get rich. By lowering taxes, we create incentive to gain wealth, and the wealth is then spent on luxury items, creating more wealth for the producers thereof, and thus raising tax revenue overall.”
I looked at the paper in front of him. He had drawn a sort of crude outline of a bell.
“And is this drawing some sort of graphic representation of your theory?” I asked.
“No. That’s just a drawing of the Liberty Bell. Sorry—I always doodle like that when I’m explaining things. It’s a nervous habit.”
“It seems to me,” said Susanna, “that the incentive to get rich is that, once you’ve done it, you’re rich. Even if you take away fifty per cent, if I make a thousand pounds, I still get to keep five hundred, so I’m five hundred pounds better off.”
Hamilton gave her a condescending smile. “I don’t expect military… uh, men to understand economics.”
“I’m sending Hamilton down to Philadelphia to explain all this to the Congress,” said Washington. “All they have to do is lower taxes and spend more money on the army, and everything will be fine.”
“Do you really think the Congress will be that…” Susanna searched for an appropriate adjective, and at last came up with “…amenable?”
“Oh,” replied Washington, “the Congress is—heh—the Congress—heh heh heh—best minds of the—ha ha ha ha ha—of the—ha ha ha ha ha!”
The laughing fit was now fully upon him, and Washington was pounding his great fists on the table, nearly upsetting the inkpot, trying to speak but finding it impossible.
“It is the effect of a puppet-show he saw last night,” I explained to poor Hamilton, who was watching with an expression of barely suppressed terror.
Washington threw his head back and exclaimed, “The blue one lives in a garbage can!” Then he fell forward, banging his forehead repeatedly on the table, so that the ink spilled all over Mr. Hamilton’s bell.
It was some time before he recovered. But eventually Mr. Hamilton was sent off to Philadelphia to persuade the Congress, and I wished him very good luck with that.
Meanwhile, things did not go well in New-York, and Washington’s strategy of doing nothing did not bear the fruit he had hoped it would bear. Even as Hamilton set off for Philadelphia, Howe, reinforced by Hessian mercenaries, invaded New-York, and our brave soldiers ran all the way across New-Jersey before they stopped. Washington eventually regrouped what was left of his army west of the Delaware, but that was not very much, most of the soldiers having deserted along the way.
All was not lost, however: two or three days after we arrived on the west bank of the Delaware, Susanna, Parson Weems, and I were very much surprised to see that little Hamilton fellow walking toward us.
“Mr. Hamilton!” I greeted him. “What a surprise to see you here! How did your mission to the Congress go?”
“Perfectly, of course,” he said, with the air of one confident that all his projects must always proceed perfectly. “I explained my ‘Drip-Down Theory’ to the Congress, which sent me back with the entire back pay of the army in specie.”
“So at last the soldiers can be paid,” Parson Weems said. “I’m sure that will come as very good news to the ones who are left. Where is the money?”
“I left it with General Washington,” replied Hamilton. “He’s down by the river in that direction.”
Weems was the first to give voice to the sudden fear that had gripped me as well. “You mean you left the General with a bag of coins? Beside a river? Alone?”
“Was that unwise?” asked Hamilton.
We said nothing; we simply began running toward the river. Susanna followed, and Hamilton trailed behind us, saying,
“Surely you don’t mean to imply that the General can’t be trusted!”
But we merely kept running for the river, whither we arrived just in time to see Washington, surrounded by empty sacks, hurling one of of the dollars the Congress had provided across the Delaware.
“What is he doing?” Susanna asked in disbelief.
“He can’t help himself,” I said to her; then to Washington, “Washington! For heaven’s sake, stop!”
“I have to stop anyway,” he said cheerfully. “I ran out of dollars.”
“But, general,” cried Susanna, “that money was all we had to pay the soldiers!”
“Was it? I suppose it was. I didn’t think of that. I saw dollars, and I saw a river, and the rest just naturally followed. My word! It felt good. I haven’t done that in a very long time.”
“But why?” Susanna demanded.
“I don’t think I understand the question,” Washington replied.
“And how will you get the dollars back?” Parson Weems asked in a mildly disapproving tone.
“By the usual method, I suppose. We’ll cross the river and retrieve them.”
“But the other side of the river is crawling with Hessians,” Weems reminded him.
“Oh—is it? I suppose it is.”
Nevertheless, there was nothing else to be done. The men had to be paid, or we should have no more army. The money was on the other side of the river. We found a few boats nearby and decided to send a small patrol across to retrieve the money if it could be done. I recommended that some subordinate officer be found to lead the patrol, but Washington would not hear of it. I therefore placed myself in Washington’s boat, with Susanna (over my objections) beside me, and we set out across the icy Delaware, fully expecting (at least for my own part) to be shot before we even reached the opposite shore.
No shots were fired, however, and when we reached the other side it became apparent why that was so. Bodies of Hessian soldiers were strewn all over the ground. At first I wondered whether some local militia had come before us and massacred the men; but as we came closer it became clear that the Hessian soldiers were not dead, but unconscious, lying in a field of Spanish milled dollars. The hail of coins had been too much for them, and each dollar hurled by the mighty arm of Washington had found its target on a Hessian skull.
“Well,” said Washington, “this is very convenient. Disarm these men and take them prisoner, and we can collect our money and our prisoners and take them back with us.”
“Or,” said Susanna, “we can bring the rest of the army across and press forward and take Trenton.”
“Would that be good?” asked Washington.
“Very good,” I told him. “The Hessian troops lie here, our prisoners. Trenton is undefended, and Trenton is the capital of the province.”
“Oh! Well, in that case, by all means. Excellent thinking, Phillips.”
Thus, having crossed the Delaware, Washington was able, by a singular stroke of good fortune, to take Trenton. The cause of independence, which had seemed so nearly hopeless after the loss of New-York, was once again embraced by public opinion.
To be continued in Chapter VIII. Or you can order the whole book now and spare yourself the wait.